Org-shared skills were unusable past the first propose. Three defects, one
root cause plus two that it masked.
ROOT CAUSE — org reads went to the personal endpoint.
`SyncClient.get_refs()` / `get_object()` only ever called `/v1/sync/refs`
and `/v1/sync/objects/:hash`. Those routes are hard-scoped server-side to
the token's own owner, so asking them for `refs/org/<id>/` returns the
caller's PERSONAL refs rather than an error, and org objects 404. Both org
call sites read org state through them:
- `pull_org_skills` resolved head=None for a populated org and reported
`{"ok": true, "head": null, "updated": []}` — org skills silently never
arrived, which reads as "my org has no skills" rather than as a failure.
- `propose_skill` resolved base_head=None, so the FIRST propose to an org
succeeded by accident (`from: null` happened to be correct) and EVERY
later one CAS'd against a head it had never seen -> 409 -> a raw
`SyncConflict` traceback. Worse, it built its root from an empty skill
map, so a landed CAS would have REPLACED the org set rather than splicing
into it — the 409 was accidentally preventing data loss.
Fix: `org_scope=True` on `get_refs`/`get_object`, threaded through
`get_commit_json`, `get_tree_json`, `_root_tree_of_commit`,
`_skill_trees_of_root`, and `materialize_tree` — walking an org commit needs
the org route on every hop, not just the first. Both org call sites now go
through one `_read_org_head()` helper.
ALSO FIXED
- `propose_skill` retries on conflict. When the org HEAD moves between the
read and the CAS (another member proposing, an admin merging), it
re-splices this one skill onto the NEW head and retries, bounded at 5
attempts. Re-splicing rather than replaying the old root is what stops a
concurrent proposal being dropped.
- An empty `actual` in a 409 means "the ref does not exist", not "here is a
commit". `SyncConflict` normalizes "" to None in its constructor, and the
personal push path redoes the CAS as a create instead of fetching "" as an
object — which surfaced as the baffling `object not found` (doubled
space). This is what a client hits after switching sync planes, since
`.sync_state` is not environment-scoped and carries a foreign head.
THE MOCK WAS THE REASON THIS SHIPPED
The test mock served org refs and org objects off the personal routes, so
21 org tests passed against a client that could not work against the real
plane. The mock now mirrors production: `/v1/sync/org/refs` and
`/v1/sync/org/objects/:hash` exist, org objects live in a separate scope,
and the personal routes refuse org content. Two existing tests had to be
corrected to assert against the org scope — they had been passing on the
mock's over-permissiveness.
Tests: 5 new (org head invisible on the personal route; second propose
splices and preserves the first; pull resolves a real org head; empty
`actual` -> None; push recovers from a stale cross-plane head). Verified
they FAIL without the fix: reverting just `_read_org_head` to the personal
route fails the second-propose test and the pre-existing splice test.
1278 passed / 0 failed across 54 suites via scripts/run_tests.sh.
Verified against PRODUCTION with a real org token, not just the mock:
- `pull_org_skills` -> head `sha256:1adf9333…`, materialized
`software-development/gateway-gateway-connector` into the `_org` mirror
(was head=None, updated=[]).
- A second `hermes sync propose` succeeded where it previously raised, and
the org set afterwards contains BOTH skills with the new commit
descending from the first.
ce6dd1a65f