Eleven new tests pinning the #29344 fix. Layout mirrors the existing
"Fix D" entitlement section so the bad-credentials disambiguator
sits alongside the entitlement-block tests it complements.
Classifier-level coverage:
* ``test_is_entitlement_failure_false_for_bad_credentials_wke_suffix``
— verbatim shape from the reporter's wire capture
(``{code: 'caller does not have permission', error: 'OAuth2 access
token could not be validated. [WKE=unauthenticated:bad-credentials]'}``)
↦ classifier must return False so the refresh path runs.
* ``test_is_entitlement_failure_false_for_wke_suffix_in_normalized_shape``
— same body after ``_extract_api_error_context`` has rewritten it
to ``{reason, message}``. The disambiguator must fire in BOTH
shapes; without this guard the production call site at
``_recover_with_credential_pool`` (which goes through the
normalised extractor) would still misclassify.
* ``test_is_entitlement_failure_false_for_any_wke_unauthenticated_variant``
— parametrised forward-compat: ``bad-credentials``,
``expired-token``, ``revoked``, ``some-future-reason``. xAI
documents the prefix as stable, the suffix after the colon as a
reason code that can grow; every variant under
``unauthenticated:`` must route to refresh.
* ``test_is_entitlement_failure_false_via_oauth2_validation_phrase_alone``
— belt-and-braces guard: if a future API revision drops the WKE
suffix but keeps "OAuth2 access token could not be validated", we
still classify correctly.
* ``test_is_entitlement_failure_wke_signal_overrides_entitlement_keywords``
— defensive: if a body ever carries BOTH the WKE suffix and
entitlement language, the WKE signal wins. Auth is recoverable;
entitlement isn't, and a refreshed token will resurface the
entitlement message on the next request.
* ``test_is_entitlement_failure_case_insensitive_wke_match`` —
pins that the classifier lowercases the haystack so a future xAI
build that uppercases the prefix doesn't reintroduce the bug.
Recovery-path coverage (end-to-end through
``_recover_with_credential_pool``):
* ``test_recover_with_credential_pool_refreshes_on_xai_bad_credentials_403``
— the headline test the reporter requested: a bad-credentials 403
with the exact wire body must call ``try_refresh_current()``
exactly once and ``_swap_credential`` once. Pre-fix this returned
``(False, _)`` because the entitlement classifier over-matched and
short-circuited the refresh path.
* ``test_recover_with_credential_pool_still_blocks_real_entitlement``
— companion regression guard for #26847: a pure unsubscribed-
account body (no WKE suffix, no OAuth2-validation phrase) must
still surface as entitlement and skip refresh. The new
disambiguator must not weaken the original loop-protection it
was added to preserve.
The scaffolding reuses ``_make_codex_agent``, ``_FakePool``, and the
existing ``MagicMock`` patterns from the surrounding tests so the
new section reads as a natural extension of "Fix D" rather than a
separate test file.
xAI partner integration requires Hermes to thread `encrypted_content`
reasoning items back to the Responses API on every turn so Grok can
maintain cross-turn reasoning coherence. PR #26644 (May 15) gated this
off for `is_xai_responses` on the theory that the OAuth/SuperGrok
surface rejected replayed encrypted blobs and produced the multi-turn
"Expected to have received \`response.created\` before \`error\`"
failure. That diagnosis was wrong — the prelude-SSE fallback added in
the same PR is what actually fixed that failure mode. Suppressing the
replay was an unnecessary side-effect that broke the whole point of
xAI's partnership integration.
Changes:
- agent/codex_responses_adapter.py — drop the `is_xai_responses` gate
in `_chat_messages_to_responses_input`. Keep the kwarg in the
signature for transport compatibility; update the docstring to
document the May 2026 reversal.
- agent/transports/codex.py — restore
`kwargs["include"] = ["reasoning.encrypted_content"]` on the xAI
Responses path so xAI echoes encrypted reasoning back to us.
- tests/run_agent/test_codex_xai_oauth_recovery.py — flip the three
xAI assertions (now: xAI MUST receive replayed reasoning AND we MUST
include encrypted_content in the request).
- tests/agent/transports/test_codex_transport.py — flip the
`include` assertions on `test_xai_reasoning_effort_passed` and
`test_xai_grok_4_omits_reasoning_effort`; update the allowlist
block comment.
The prelude-SSE fallback and the entitlement-403 surfacing fixes from
#26644 are untouched — they were independent fixes that happened to
ride along with the reasoning-replay gate.
Validation:
- Targeted: tests/run_agent/test_codex_xai_oauth_recovery.py +
tests/agent/transports/test_codex_transport.py → 65/65 pass
- Broader: tests/agent/transports/ + tests/run_agent/ →
1674 passed, 3 skipped, 0 failures
- E2E (real imports, isolated HERMES_HOME, ResponsesApiTransport
build_kwargs): turn-1 request carries
`include: ["reasoning.encrypted_content"]`; turn-2 input replays
the encrypted_content blob from turn-1's
`codex_reasoning_items`; native Codex unchanged.
Tests:
* ``test_refresh_xai_oauth_pure_403_marked_tier_denied_not_relogin`` —
refresh-403 raises ``xai_oauth_tier_denied`` with
``relogin_required=False`` and the API-key fallback hint in body.
* ``test_format_auth_error_tier_denied_does_not_suggest_relogin`` —
the renderer does not append "Run ``hermes model``" for the new
code.
* ``test_recover_with_credential_pool_skips_refresh_on_bare_403_for_xai_oauth`` —
bare ``{"reason":"forbidden","message":"Forbidden"}`` body (which
does not match the existing keyword heuristic) still short-circuits
``try_refresh_current`` on xai-oauth.
Docs:
* Drop the "(any active tier)" claim from the xai-grok-oauth guide,
add a top-of-page warning callout, and a Troubleshooting section
for the 403-after-login case pointing at ``XAI_API_KEY`` +
``provider: xai`` as the documented fallback.
When xAI returns a subscription/entitlement error through an SSE
``type=error`` frame, ``_StreamErrorEvent`` is raised with
``status_code=None``. This caused ``_classify_by_status`` (step 2 of
``classify_api_error``) to be skipped entirely, and the Grok-specific
phrases ("do not have an active Grok subscription", "out of available
resources") appeared in none of the message-pattern lists. The error
fell through to ``FailoverReason.unknown (retryable=True)``, burning
``max_retries`` on every affected X Premium+ / SuperGrok user before
the agent stopped — and ``_is_entitlement_failure`` was never called
because it only fires under ``FailoverReason.auth``.
The HTTP 403 path already handled this correctly (``_classify_by_status``
returns ``auth/non-retryable`` for 403). Add an explicit pattern block
at step 1 (highest priority, before the ``status_code`` guard) so both
code paths route to ``FailoverReason.auth, retryable=False,
should_fallback=True`` — matching the 403 path exactly.
Add three regression tests in ``Fix D`` section of
``test_codex_xai_oauth_recovery.py``:
- primary "do not have an active Grok subscription" phrase
- "out of available resources" + "grok" variant
- unrelated ``_StreamErrorEvent`` must not be reclassified
xAI announced on 2026-05-16 (https://x.ai/news/grok-hermes) that X Premium
subscriptions now work in Hermes Agent. The hint we shipped in PR #26644
asserted the opposite ("X Premium+ does NOT include xAI API access — only
standalone SuperGrok subscribers can use this provider"), which would now
misdirect Premium+ users who hit any other 403 (no Grok sub at all, wrong
tier, exhausted quota) into thinking they need to switch subscriptions
when their sub is in fact valid.
Remove _decorate_xai_entitlement_error and its two call sites in
_summarize_api_error. xAI's own body text already says "Manage subscriptions
at https://grok.com/?_s=usage" — surface that verbatim and let xAI's wording
do the diagnosis.
The _is_entitlement_failure guard (which prevents credential-pool refresh
loops on entitlement 403s) and the reasoning-replay gating for xai-oauth
are unrelated and untouched.
Update tests to assert the body still surfaces verbatim and that no
Hermes-side editorializing is appended.
The #1 confusing cause of the xAI 403 (per Teknium): X Premium+
subscribers see Grok inside the X app and assume API access is
included. It is NOT — only standalone SuperGrok subscribers can use
xai-oauth with Hermes today. Without calling this out, every Premium+
user hits the 403 with no idea why.
PR #26666's neutral 4-cause list was correct but buried the most
common cause. Lead with the Premium+ gotcha, then list the other
possibilities (no subscription, wrong tier, exhausted quota) as
fallbacks. Same neutral framing — does not accuse anyone of being
unsubscribed.
PR #26644 confidently told users "xAI OAuth account lacks SuperGrok /
X Premium entitlement" on any 403 from xAI's permission-denied surface.
But that body is returned for at least four distinct causes that
Hermes cannot distinguish from the wire:
* Account has no Grok subscription at all
* Account has SuperGrok but the tier doesn't include the requested
model (e.g. grok-4.3 needs SuperGrok Heavy)
* Monthly quota for the subscribed tier is exhausted
* SuperGrok is active but the API access add-on isn't enabled
Don Piedro pushed back that he IS subscribed yet still hit this.
Picking the worst-case interpretation ("you're not subscribed")
reads as wrong and insulting to subscribers, and points them at a
fix they already did.
New wording lists all 4 possibilities and points at
https://grok.com/?_s=usage where the user can check which applies.
The detection logic and credential-pool short-circuit (PR #26664)
are unchanged — only the user-facing wording is rephrased.
Don Piedro's 18-minute hang on grok-4.3 traced to two issues PR #26644
didn't cover:
- _recover_with_credential_pool classifies 403 as FailoverReason.auth
and calls pool.try_refresh_current(). For xAI OAuth on an
unsubscribed account, refresh succeeds (mints a new token from the
same account) but the next API call 403s with the same entitlement
error. Result: infinite refresh → retry → 403 loop until Ctrl+C
(1133s in Don's log). New _is_entitlement_failure(error_context,
status_code) detects the subscription-shape body ("do not have an
active Grok subscription" / "out of available resources" + grok /
"does not have permission" + grok) and short-circuits recovery so
_summarize_api_error surfaces PR #26644's friendly hint.
- grok-4.3 resolved to 256k via the grok-4 catch-all in
DEFAULT_CONTEXT_LENGTHS. Per docs.x.ai/developers/models/grok-4.3
the model ships with 1M context. Add explicit grok-4.3 entry
before the grok-4 fallback (longest-first substring matching
ensures grok-4.3 and grok-4.3-latest both land on the new value).
Tests: 8 new (23 total in test_codex_xai_oauth_recovery.py).
E2E verified Don's 100-iteration loop bails out with 0 refresh calls
while genuine auth failures still refresh once and recover.
Three fixes for the May 2026 xAI OAuth (SuperGrok / X Premium) rollout
failures:
- _run_codex_stream: when openai SDK raises RuntimeError("Expected to
have received `response.created` before `<type>`"), retry once then
fall back to responses.create(stream=True) — same path used for
missing-response.completed postlude. Fallback surfaces the real
provider error with body+status_code intact. Also fixes#8133
(response.in_progress prelude on custom relays) and #14634
(codex.rate_limits prelude on codex-lb).
- _summarize_api_error: when error body matches xAI's entitlement
shape, append a one-line hint pointing to https://grok.com and
/model. Once-only, applies to both auxiliary warnings and
main-loop error surfacing.
- _chat_messages_to_responses_input: new is_xai_responses kwarg
drops replayed codex_reasoning_items (encrypted_content) before
they reach xAI. Also drops reasoning.encrypted_content from the
xAI include array. Native Codex behavior unchanged. Grok still
reasons natively each turn; coherence rides on visible message
text alone.
Closes#8133, #14634.
