Follow-ups for salvaged #53784:
- reference_timeout now defaults to None = no per-preset override, so the
reference fan-out inherits auxiliary.moa_reference.timeout (900s default)
via call_llm's own per-task timeout resolution. The PR's 30.0s default
would have cut off long-thinking advisors mid-response, and its 300s max
cap capped legitimate explicit values — both removed. Explicit per-preset
values are still honored as-is.
- _is_failed_reference also treats '[skipped: …]' recursion-guard notes as
internal sentinels, keeping them out of both aggregator prompts.
- Dashboard/desktop TS types updated to number | null; web_server validator
accepts null/empty as 'inherit'.
Keep MoA reference display events off the machine-readable -Q stdout
surface (platform=cli with tool_progress_mode=off) while preserving them
everywhere else. Extracts the relay into module-level helpers so the
policy is testable.
Salvaged from #67334.
Follow-up to the #67690 salvage (@m4r13y). The PR's tools/env_probe.py
hunk was written against the old capture_output=True _run(); #67964/#67999
rewrote _run to temp-file capture on July 20, so that hunk no longer
applied — but the rewritten _run still lacked creationflags and kept
flashing one console per probe (~5 per kanban worker start) from
windowless parents. Re-implement the one-line fix against the current
shape: creationflags=windows_hide_flags() on the temp-file subprocess.run,
preserving the #67964 grandchild-can't-wedge-the-pipe contract.
Also add the tests the PR didn't ship, in
tests/test_windows_subprocess_no_window_flags.py:
- env_probe._run passes CREATE_NO_WINDOW and keeps temp-file (non-PIPE)
stdout/stderr + DEVNULL stdin
- lazy_deps uv install / pip --version probe / pip install fallback /
ensurepip bootstrap all pass CREATE_NO_WINDOW
- suppress_platform_ver_console: POSIX no-op (platform._syscmd_ver
untouched, win32_ver() still returns), and simulated-Windows stubbing
(echo stub installed, idempotent, never raises)
The per-advisor enabled toggle adds enabled=True to normalized slots;
the JSON-string-parse and per-slot max_tokens tests from sibling
clusters asserted exact dicts. Compare against the enabled-augmented
expectation instead.
The per-reference-model enabled toggle (#59753 salvage) intentionally adds
'enabled' to normalized slot dicts. The two endpoint tests asserted the
exact key set {provider, model} — convert them to subset + round-trip
contracts so optional slot keys (enabled, reasoning_effort, max_tokens)
don't break them again.
Follow-up for salvaged PR #59753 rebased over the per-slot
reasoning_effort feature: _clean_slot now round-trips reasoning_effort
AND enabled together; add a normalize→normalize regression test, update
the validate/normalize agreement contract for the canonical enabled
default, restore the desktop per-slot toggle test on the current
autosave editor, and map oppenheimor's contributor email.
Adds per-reference progress events and a phase-transition marker to the
MoA display pipeline so TUI / CLI / desktop surfaces can render a status
bar like `MOA: 2/3 refs done` and surface which phase (reference vs
aggregator) is currently active.
- `moa.progress` — fired once per reference completion with
`refs_done`, `refs_total`, and the source label
- `moa.phase` — fired on phase transitions (currently the single
`phase="aggregator"` transition once the fan-out
finishes)
Plumbed through the existing `reference_callback` →
`tool_progress_callback` → gateway path; no new UI surface. The legacy
`moa.reference` / `moa.aggregating` events are unchanged for backwards
compatibility.
AI-assisted fix by https://github.com/SquabbyZ/peaks-loop
Regression tests for the #47971 salvage: the LSP language-server spawn
must pass windows_hide_flags() creationflags while keeping PIPE stdio
and start_new_session, and the npm/go LSP auto-installer subprocess.run
calls must carry the same hide flags with DEVNULL stdin and
capture_output intact.
The Windows /restart watcher's outer Popen spawns the watcher with
windows_detach_popen_kwargs() (which carries CREATE_BREAKAWAY_FROM_JOB),
but a restrictive parent job object can reject that bit with OSError and
the current call has no retry. Preserve the current watcher
implementation and add a focused breakaway-denied fallback.
Preserved from current main: watcher_python / pythonw.exe selection, the
str(restart_after_s) deadline, the scrubbed watcher_env, the intentional
no-breakaway inline respawn, and the entire POSIX setsid/bash path.
- primary keeps **windows_detach_popen_kwargs()
- on OSError, retry the same argv/env with
creationflags=windows_detach_flags_without_breakaway()
- on dual failure, log a definitive, path-safe warning (interpreter
basename + numeric winerror/errno only) and return without crashing
Replace the superseded breakaway-first inline design and its AST tests
with focused behavioral coverage that drives the real coroutine with a
mocked subprocess.Popen (retry, argv/env/DEVNULL preservation, POSIX
single-session kwarg, no-breakaway inline respawn, secret-safe logging).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds moa.privacy_filter ('' | display | full, default off — issue #59959):
- display: redact user-visible surfaces only (reference blocks emitted to
the UI + saved MoA trace records, including per-advisor full input/output
and the aggregator-input copy); the aggregator sees raw advisor text so
synthesis quality is unaffected.
- full: additionally redact the advisor text injected into the aggregator
prompt, on both the persistent facade path and the one-shot /moa
synthesis path (the issue's literal ask). Legacy boolean true maps here.
Secret/credential shapes (API-key prefixes, JWTs, private keys, DB
connection strings) are delegated to the central redactor
(agent.redact.redact_sensitive_text, force=True + code_file=True); the MoA
filter adds only email and clearly delimited phone-number patterns. No
bare 10-digit matching: line numbers, timestamps, epoch values, git SHAs,
IPs, versions, and source-code assignments in code-review-shaped advisory
text pass through byte-identical. The reference cache always holds raw
text — redaction happens at each consuming surface, so a mid-session mode
change never leaks or double-redacts.
Reworked from PR #60463: replaced its hand-rolled pattern list (which
matched bare digit runs and re-implemented key shapes) with central-
redactor reuse + safe patterns, and split the single boolean into
display/full modes. Credited for the feature framing.
Co-authored-by: webtecnica <75556242+webtecnica@users.noreply.github.com>
Extends the fanout enum with 'every_n:<N>' (N >= 2): advisors run on the
first iteration of each user turn and every Nth tool iteration after it;
off-cadence iterations REUSE the cached guidance from the last on-cadence
run via the same cache mechanism the user_turn fanout uses, so the
aggregator still gets advice on every step. The cadence counter is scoped
per user turn (resets on a new user message) and only advances when the
advisory state actually changes, so streaming retries never consume a
cadence slot. Mapping form {mode: every_n, n: N} normalizes to the
canonical string. Unknown/degenerate values fall back to per_iteration.
Addresses issue #63393 (advisor fan-out multiplies turn latency/cost by
the tool-iteration count). Redesigned from PR #63448: the submitted shape
skipped references entirely on off-cadence iterations (aggregator ran
advice-less); this version keeps the last advice in play, credited for
the idea and cadence framing.
Config-gated, default-off (default fanout remains per_iteration).
Co-authored-by: webtecnica <75556242+webtecnica@users.noreply.github.com>
Adds test_moa_gemini_aggregator_sanitize_uses_real_model: drives a full MoA
tool-call turn (virtual-provider mode) with a Gemini aggregator and asserts
the strict-API sanitize pass is invoked with the resolved aggregator model
(gemini-3-pro-preview), never the virtual preset name once a slot is
resolved — the exact path that stripped extra_content/thought_signature and
made Gemini aggregators 400 (#65092).
Writing the test surfaced a gap in the salvaged #66212 fix: in virtual-
provider MoA mode (provider=moa, no moa_config threaded through
run_conversation) the conversation-loop branch never fired because it only
consulted moa_config. Extend it to fall back to the facade's
last_aggregator_slot — the same source the handle_max_iterations fix uses —
so both MoA entry modes resolve the real aggregator model.
Also adds the contributors/emails mapping for the #15676 credit base.
Follow-ups to the salvaged core of #60293:
- Gate the x-initiator header on _normalize_aux_provider() instead of a
literal 'copilot' string compare, so slot configs spelled github /
github-copilot / github-models / copilot-acp / mixed case all get the
user-turn attribution.
- Thread extra_headers through _retry_same_provider_sync/_async so the
credential-refresh and pool-rotation retry rebuilds don't silently drop
the header (the rebuilt kwargs previously started from scratch).
- Add a transport-boundary test asserting the header reaches the SDK
client's create() kwargs (no call_llm mocking), an alias-spelling
matrix test, and a retry-rebuild preservation test.
Follow-up to the salvaged core of #53802: a naive MoAClient(preset) rebuild
restores a working facade but silently drops the reference_callback relay
wired in agent_init, so moa.reference / moa.aggregating display events stop
reaching every frontend for the rest of the session.
Introduce agent.moa_loop.build_moa_facade(agent, preset) as the single
construction point for the MoA facade and use it at:
- initial client construction (agent_init.py)
- turn-start fallback restore (restore_primary_runtime)
- transient transport recovery (try_recover_primary_transport — previously
fell through to _create_openai_client with MoA's empty client_kwargs and
died with 'api_key client option must be set')
- mid-session model switches (switch_model)
The relay reads agent.tool_progress_callback at emit time, so callbacks
attached after construction are picked up automatically.
Adds test_moa_restored_facade_still_emits_reference_events covering event
delivery through a restored facade.
When Hermes fails over from a non-Gemini provider (xAI, Anthropic, etc.) to
Gemini mid-conversation, the existing assistant tool_calls in history carry
no Gemini ``extra_content.google.thought_signature`` (the originating provider
never emits one). The native adapter's ``_translate_tool_call_to_gemini``
omitted ``thoughtSignature`` entirely in that case, so Gemini 3 thinking
models rejected every replayed turn with::
HTTP 400 INVALID_ARGUMENT
Function call is missing a thought_signature in functionCall parts.
Additional data, function call default_api:<tool_name>, position N.
The Cloud Code Assist sibling adapter already handles this exact case by
emitting a sentinel ``"skip_thought_signature_validator"`` (see
``agent/gemini_cloudcode_adapter.py:106``, originally added in #11270 and
documented as matching ``opencode-gemini-auth``'s approach). This change
mirrors that fallback in the native adapter so the two paths behave
identically when replaying cross-provider history.
Verified live against ``generativelanguage.googleapis.com/v1beta`` with
``gemini-3-pro-preview``: synthetic 2-turn conversation with no real
``thoughtSignature`` returns 400 without the sentinel and 200 with it.
Test added: ``test_build_native_request_emits_sentinel_for_cross_provider_tool_call``.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Follow-up fixes on top of the salvaged #22566 mechanism:
- N-collector now counts only REAL actionable user turns via
_is_actionable_user_turn + _is_synthetic_compression_user_turn —
the same filter pair _find_last_user_message_idx uses post-#69291.
The contributor's bare role=='user' + _is_context_summary_content
check let blank platform echoes and continuation/todo rows consume
N slots, silently degrading the guarantee.
- Default flipped 3 -> 1 (behavior-preserving): a default of 3 was
measured to change the tail cut on transcripts whose budget covers
only the last turn. min_tail_user_messages=1 delegates to the
existing single-user anchor; N>1 is opt-in, and the call site is
gated so the default path is byte-identical to main.
- Hardened config parse in agent_init (bool rejected, fractional
floats rejected, floor 1) matching the max_attempts parser shape.
- Wired the recurring external-PR config gaps: hermes_cli/config.py
DEFAULT_CONFIG + cli-config.yaml.example (PR only had cli.py).
- Regression tests: blank echoes / synthetic rows don't count toward
N; tool-call/result pairs never split by the N-boundary (no-orphan
both directions); N-guarantee wins over tail_token_budget and the
_MAX_TAIL_MESSAGE_FLOOR (floor is a minimum, not a cap); default
parity pin; DEFAULT_CONFIG pin.
Add _ensure_last_n_user_messages_in_tail to guarantee the last N user
messages survive compression in the uncompressed tail, with surrounding
assistant/tool context preserved.
- Add min_tail_user_messages parameter (default 3) to ContextCompressor
- New _ensure_last_n_user_messages_in_tail method generalizes single-user protection
- Skip context-summary handoff banners when counting user messages
- User messages are clean boundaries — skip _align_boundary_backward
- Wire through cli.py, agent_init.py, and gateway cache busting keys
Config:
compression:
min_tail_user_messages: 3
Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
_collect_ghosted_skill_names() covers both ghost-skill shapes in the
compressed middle window: rows already demoted to a [SKILL_PRUNED: ...]
marker AND raw skill_view bodies (> _SKILL_VIEW_PRUNE_MIN_CHARS) that
survived Phase-1 inside an earlier protected tail and then aged into the
compression window — the summarizer paraphrases those instructions away
too. Shared threshold constant between the emit site and the scan.
Pinned by a live-probe-shaped test (real compress(), mocked aux LLM).
21 tests pinning the salvaged #44166 behavior:
- marker emit + extractor round trip (patterns adapted from PR #32375
by @LeonSGP43, with credit)
- no-duplicate re-injection when the canonical marker survived (the
original PR's presence-check defect)
- Phase-1 protection for just-loaded / user-referenced skills, and the
Pass-4 pressure override that keeps #61932 fixed
- deterministic marker survival through a REAL compress() with a mocked
aux LLM: drop → re-injected, keep → not duplicated, static-fallback
path, iterative re-compression via rehydrated handoff
- markers never classify as handoff content (classify_summary_content /
_strip_context_summary_handoff_message untouched)
- SKILLS_GUIDANCE Skill Safety Rule renders with real newlines
Community verification of #56688 (zmack12344321) found two follow-up gaps
that kept Vertex invisible in the /model menu even after registry
registration:
1. hermes_cli/model_switch.py: list_authenticated_providers() had a
credential gate hard-coded to API keys (with an aws_sdk special case
only) — add a vertex branch using has_vertex_credentials(), mirroring
the aws_sdk shape.
2. hermes_cli/models.py: Vertex's OpenAI-compatible endpoint has no
/models listing route, so without a curated _PROVIDER_MODELS entry the
picker only ever showed the current model — add a Gemini curated list.
Follow-up to #56688.
The Vertex AI provider (added same-day, commit c73e74386) was never added to
either of the two provider registries that agent/auxiliary_client.py and the
MoA slot-resolution chain depend on, breaking Vertex outside the main
conversation loop:
1. hermes_cli/auth.py::PROVIDER_REGISTRY had no "vertex" entry. The
plugin-auto-extend loop that normally fills gaps explicitly skips
non-api_key auth types (`if _pp.auth_type != "api_key": continue`), and
Vertex was never hand-declared like "bedrock" is. Because
resolve_provider_client() in agent/auxiliary_client.py gates everything
on `pconfig = PROVIDER_REGISTRY.get(provider)` and returns (None, None)
immediately when pconfig is None, its `elif pconfig.auth_type == "vertex"`
branch was permanently dead code — every auxiliary Vertex call (vision,
title generation, reflection, context compression, MoA reference/
aggregator slots) failed outright, not just a MoA-specific edge case.
2. hermes_cli/providers.py::HERMES_OVERLAYS also had no "vertex" entry, so
hermes_cli.providers.get_provider("vertex") returned None. This backs
_preserve_provider_with_base_url() in agent/auxiliary_client.py, which a
MoA slot's resolved (base_url, api_key) pair needs to keep its "vertex"
identity instead of silently collapsing to "custom" — losing the
identity _refresh_provider_credentials() needs to re-mint an expired
OAuth2 token (~1h lifetime) on a 401, and permanently breaking every
subsequent call in that MoA preset for the rest of the session.
Fix mirrors the existing "bedrock"/aws_sdk entries in both registries
exactly, plus adds a "vertex" branch to _refresh_provider_credentials() (it
had branches for openai-codex/nous/anthropic/xai-oauth but not vertex,
so a 401 fell through to `return False` without evicting the stale cached
client).
- hermes_cli/auth.py: hand-declared vertex ProviderConfig(auth_type="vertex")
in PROVIDER_REGISTRY, matching bedrock's shape.
- hermes_cli/providers.py: vertex HermesOverlay(auth_type="vertex") in
HERMES_OVERLAYS + "Google Vertex AI" label override.
- agent/auxiliary_client.py: vertex branch in _refresh_provider_credentials
that re-mints the token via get_vertex_config() and evicts the stale
cached client.
- 8 new regression tests across tests/hermes_cli/test_vertex_provider.py and
tests/agent/test_auxiliary_client.py: registry membership, end-to-end
resolve_provider_client("vertex", ...) building a working client (proving
the previously-dead branch is now reachable), and the 401-refresh/cache-
eviction path.
MoaConfigPayload does not declare save_traces or trace_dir, so
set_moa_models() overwrites cfg["moa"] with a dict that lacks these
hand-edited keys. Use dict.update() to merge instead of replace.
Fixes#58819
MoA (Mixture of Agents) is a legitimate internal provider used by
Diagnosis presets and multi-model aggregation. When a MoA preset sets
model.provider to 'moa', hermes doctor incorrectly reports it as
'unrecognised' and suggests changing it, which would break the MoA setup.
Add 'moa' to the known_providers set alongside 'openrouter', 'custom',
and 'auto' so doctor recognises it as valid.
Fixes#58759
The existing tests cover _normalize_moa_model() in isolation and a local
precedence expression, but not the __init__ wiring itself. Add two
init-level regression tests: constructing HermesCLI(model='moa:strategy')
strips the prefix to model='strategy' and forces requested_provider='moa',
and the moa: prefix wins over an explicit --provider. Both fail if the
override is dropped from the requested_provider resolution.
Refs #56828
hermes chat -Q -m moa:strategy failed with 'model moa:strategy is not
supported' (HTTP 401/400): the raw model string was passed straight to
the real provider. The MoA virtual provider only got wired up through the
interactive /moa command and the model picker, never through the -Q
one-shot startup path.
resolve_runtime_provider already handles requested_provider == 'moa', and
agent_init builds the MoAClient off provider == 'moa' (surface-agnostic).
The only gap was mapping the moa:<preset> model string to that provider.
Add _normalize_moa_model() and apply it in HermesCLI.__init__ before
provider resolution: a moa:<preset> model sets requested_provider='moa'
and model=<preset>, so the existing MoA path runs in non-interactive mode
too. The moa: prefix wins over an explicit --provider (previously
--provider deepseek -m moa:strategy silently dropped MoA).
Fixes#56828
Follow-ups on top of the cherry-picked #27748 mechanism:
- move the cap constant to module level with full rationale comment
(class attribute aliases it so subclasses/tests can override)
- bound the iterative-update path too: the PREVIOUS SUMMARY block is
passed through _bound_summary_input so a pathological rehydrated
handoff cannot blow up the prompt (previous summary + new turns each
capped)
- extra regression tests: byte-identical small-input passthrough
(identity), direct bound+marker unit check, bound-after-per-message-
truncation shape (hundreds of under-_CONTENT_MAX turns), iterative
path bounded, marker vs classify_summary_content non-collision
- contributor email mapping for @robgfl45
Follow-ups on top of the cherry-picked #62644 mechanism, porting it to
current main and closing the salvage-review requirements:
- proactive_prune_min_reclaim_tokens (default 4096): a prune only COMMITS
when it reclaims a meaningful token batch, measured on the pruned output.
A committed prune rewrites already-sent history and invalidates the
provider prompt-cache prefix; this hysteresis gate keeps those breaks
episodic/amortized (like a compression boundary) instead of firing every
tool iteration. 0 disables the gate. (Design point credited to the
#62389 review cycle's prune_minimum_tokens.)
- Standard no-op caller contract: every skip path returns the INPUT list
object; the loop commits only on 'result is not messages' + non-zero count.
- Loop call is getattr+callable guarded (plugin engines predating the hook,
SimpleNamespace test doubles) and exception-swallowed at debug level.
- Config parse follows the compression.max_attempts hardened semantics:
booleans rejected, fractional floats rejected, integral floats/numeric
strings accepted; negative trigger = disabled.
- cli-config.yaml.example documented (all three keys) and gateway
_CACHE_BUSTING_CONFIG_KEYS extended so hot-reload rebuilds the agent.
- Tests: min-reclaim gate both directions, input-object no-op contract,
no-orphan tool_call_id pairing in BOTH directions (#69830 pin rule),
default-off zero-behavior-change pin, config parse seam, and behavioral
loop-wiring tests (consulted/commit/no-op/absent-method/raising).
The phase-1 tool-result prune only runs inside compress(), which fires
near 50% of the context window, so it never triggers on large-window
models; old tool outputs then ride in history and are re-sent every turn.
Add prune_tool_results_only(): the same no-LLM prune on a separate, low
proactive_prune_tokens trigger, run as an elif to the compression branch.
Opt-in (default 0), protects the recent tail by message count.
Add the method to the ContextEngine base as a no-op default so pluggable
engines inherit it safely (the post-tool-call path never AttributeErrors on
a non-built-in engine); the built-in compressor supplies the real prune.
Register both keys under the top-level compression config with defaults and
document them.
Interrupted turns can seed a speculative display token count before the provider receives the request. Restore that display-only seed when interruption wins the race, while preserving completed post-compaction state and treating a successful provider response independently of optional usage metadata.
Constraint: #54776 remains reproducible on current main, while review #4702305384 identifies anti-thrashing rollback as stale and usage receipt as an unreliable response-completion signal.
Rejected: Restore anti-thrashing counters from a preflight snapshot | current main derives their verdict from real provider usage after a completed compaction boundary.
Confidence: high
Scope-risk: narrow
Directive: Keep interrupted preflight rollback display-only, and never infer provider completion from the presence of usage metadata.
Tested: ./.venv/bin/python -m pytest -q tests/run_agent/test_413_compression.py (29 passed); turn-finalizer/conversation-loop tests (31 passed); context-compressor targeted tests (12 passed); infinite-compaction targeted tests (3 passed); ruff; git diff --check.
Not-tested: End-to-end interactive interrupt through CLI or gateway transport.
Gateway half of the #49874 salvage: pass compression_deferred through
both _run_agent_inner result dicts and guard the compression-exhausted
auto-reset block with it — a lock-contended defer keeps the session
intact (the concurrent compressor is actively shrinking it) instead of
wiping it via reset_session.
Regression tests:
- tests/run_agent/test_compression_lock_defer.py — provider-mock 413 and
400-overflow turns whose compression pass lost the lock end as
compression_deferred (failed=False, no compression_exhausted); flag
unset keeps the terminal exhaustion path byte-identical; type-pin
tests vs MagicMock agents and junk flag values; cap=1 e2e proving the
refunded pre-API defer leaves the budget for the provider-proven
413 retry.
- tests/agent/test_preflight_lock_defer.py — a lock-skipped preflight
pass stops the loop WITHOUT arming preflight_compression_blocked;
plain no-op still arms it; MagicMock junk does not defer.
- tests/gateway/test_compression_deferred_soft_result.py — AST pin that
the deferred branch guards the auto-reset chain and performs no
session mutation (mirrors test_35809_auto_reset_clean_context.py).
Hardening on top of the salvaged dead-PID lease reclamation from PR #65775
(@the3asic):
- Probe via psutil.pid_exists (hard dependency; CONTRIBUTING.md critical
rule #1) with the contributor's os.kill(pid, 0) POSIX probe retained
only as a scaffold-phase fallback when psutil is missing.
- Same-process holders (pid == os.getpid()) are never probed and never
self-reclaimed — another thread's live lease is owned by the lease
refresher/release path.
- Any probe doubt (exceptions, permission errors) conservatively keeps
the lease until normal TTL expiry; Windows stays TTL-only.
- Tests: psutil-first dead-pid reclaim (probe call pinned), os.kill
fallback path, probe-doubt keeps lease, same-pid no self-reclaim,
legacy holder + Windows paths assert NO probe via either API.
compress_trajectory (and _async) replaced the compressible middle region with
a [CONTEXT SUMMARY] turn without checking that the region is actually larger
than the summary. When a large protected system prompt dominates the budget,
the compressible middle can be tiny; replacing e.g. a 2-token middle with a
~60-token summary GROWS the trajectory (tokens_saved negative), marks it
was_compressed, and still spends a summarization call — the opposite of the
intent, on exactly the hard over-budget cases.
Add a net-savings guard mirroring the code's own comment (net_savings =
region_tokens - summary_target_tokens): if the safely-compressible region is
no larger than summary_target_tokens, return the trajectory unchanged. Applied
to both the sync and async paths. Add sync+async regression tests.
MoA reference_max_tokens is preset-level — one cap for all reference
models. When mixing a verbose model with a terse one, a single cap is
either too tight for the terse model or too loose for the verbose one.
Now each reference slot can optionally carry its own max_tokens:
reference_models:
- provider: openrouter
model: deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro
max_tokens: *** # per-slot cap, overrides preset-level
- provider: openai-codex
model: gpt-5.5
# no max_tokens → falls back to preset-level reference_max_tokens
_clean_slot (moa_config.py) preserves an optional max_tokens field on
the slot dict, coerced via _coerce_int_or_none. _run_reference
(moa_loop.py) reads slot-level max_tokens first, falling back to the
preset-level cap passed by the caller. Slots without the field are
unaffected — backward compatible.
Type hints on slot-handling functions updated from dict[str, str] to
dict[str, Any] to reflect the now-heterogeneous slot shape.
Requested in review: builder-level assertions that the gemini-native
branch forwards max_tokens (provider names and the native
generativelanguage.googleapis.com base_url, max_tokens=600), plus a
control showing gemini models on OpenAI-compatible endpoints — including
Gemini's own /openai compatibility endpoint — keep the existing omission
behavior (#34530).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Per review feedback from teknium1: reference_max_tokens is an advisors-only
contract. The aggregator is the acting model and must not be capped by the
reference budget. Changed _is_moa from startswith('moa_') to exact match on
'moa_reference'. Added regression test proving aggregator does NOT receive
max_tokens.
Copilot review pointed out that hardcoding kwargs['max_tokens'] would
400 on models requiring max_completion_tokens (GPT-5 family, Copilot).
The existing auxiliary_max_tokens_param() helper already selects the
correct parameter name per model — use it instead of hardcoding.
Test updated to parametrize expected_key so the Copilot gpt-5.5 case
correctly asserts max_completion_tokens instead of max_tokens.
Addresses Copilot review comments on both files.
