When a tool call itself restarts the gateway (docker restart, systemctl
restart, and similar), the process is terminated mid-call — before the
tool result is persisted and before the orderly drain rewind can run. The
transcript tail is left as an assistant(tool_calls) with no matching tool
answer. On resume the model re-issues the unanswered call, taking the
gateway down again — an infinite loop (#49201).
Source fix: _build_gateway_agent_history now strips a trailing
assistant(tool_calls) block that has no tool answers
(_strip_dangling_tool_call_tail), so there is nothing for the model to
re-execute. This complements _strip_interrupted_tool_tails, which only
handles the case where a tool result row exists with an interrupt marker.
Cognitive backstop: the resume-pending system note now states that any
restart command in the history already ran and must not be re-executed or
verified, and the empty-message auto-resume startup turn reports recovery
and asks for instructions instead of the nonsensical "address the user's
NEW message" (there is no new message on that turn).
Reimplements the intent of #49243 by @JoaoMarcos44 at the replay layer.
Fixes#49201
Teams overrode send_image/send_image_file but not send_video, send_voice,
or send_document — so when the gateway dispatched a video/voice/document
reply to a Teams chat it fell through to the base-class text fallback and
sent the local file path as plain text (same broken-UX class as the LINE
URL-image gap in #49298).
Extract the existing send_image attachment logic into a shared
_send_media_attachment helper (remote URL by reference, local file as a
base64 data URI, MIME guessed from the path) and route all four media
kinds through it. 5 new tests cover remote-URL, local-file base64,
no-app, and missing-file paths.
Simplify pass on the picker-persist coverage:
- Stub list_picker_providers + resolve_display_context_length so the
tests no longer make real outbound HTTP calls (OpenRouter catalog +
Ollama /api/show) during picker setup and confirmation rendering.
Runtime drops from ~11s to ~0.4s and the tests are now deterministic.
- Collapse the two positive persist cases into one parametrize over the
config seed (nested-dict vs flat-string), asserting the nested-dict
invariant in both.
- Assert the in-memory session override is applied in the --session
case, closing a 'passes for the wrong reason' gap (config untouched
AND the switch still took effect).
- _FakePickerResult -> types.SimpleNamespace.
Mutation re-checked on the final test: both persist cases fail on
pre-fix slash_commands.py; the --session case passes on both.
Add regression coverage for the picker persist fix: drive the real
_handle_model_command with a fake picker-capable adapter that captures
the on_model_selected callback, fire a 'tap', and assert config.yaml is
written (bare /model), left untouched (--session), and that a flat-string
model: is coerced to a nested dict on a tap.
Mutation-checked: the persist and coercion assertions fail on pre-fix
slash_commands.py and pass on the fix.
Auto-generated session titles already rename the Telegram forum topic via
the title_callback path, but the /title command only wrote the session
title to the database. On a Telegram topic lane the visible topic kept its
auto-assigned name, so a user who ran /title to override it saw no change.
Propagate the user-chosen title to the topic by calling the existing
_schedule_telegram_topic_title_rename helper on a successful /title set. It
already no-ops off Telegram topic lanes and when auto-rename is disabled.
* fix(discord): hydrate channel context when replying to a message
Replying to a message in a free-response (non-mention, threads-off)
channel previously received only the 500-char "[Replying to: ...]"
snippet — the history-backfill gate fired only for mention-gated
channels and threads, so a reply got no surrounding channel context.
Replies now route through the same _fetch_channel_context hydration
that threads use. When the user replied to a specific (often older)
message, a reply-anchored window is scanned ending at that message so
the agent sees the exchange around what was pointed at, even when the
target sits before the self-message partition. The two windows are
merged chronologically and de-duplicated by message id.
Also hardens the recent-window scan to skip non-conversational status
bumps before the self-message partition check, and makes author-name
resolution defensive against partial/deleted authors.
* fix(discord): duck-type reply-target resolution instead of isinstance(discord.Message)
The e2e suite stubs the discord module, so discord.Message is a MagicMock
and isinstance(_resolved, discord.Message) raises 'isinstance() arg 2 must
be a type'. Any object with an int .id works as a scan anchor, so resolve
the reply target by duck-typing on .id and fall back to a _Snowflake from
the reference message_id.
Sets the Telegram bot's short description (the line under its name) to
"Online" on gateway connect and "Offline" on clean disconnect, gated
behind extra.status_indicator (off by default).
Telegram bots have no presence/online dot — that's a user-account
feature the Bot API doesn't expose for bots. The short description is
the closest available surface, so this gives users a way to tell whether
the gateway is up from the bot's profile.
- New extra.status_indicator flag (+ status_online/status_offline text
overrides), read in __init__ via config.extra — no config-schema change.
- _set_status_indicator() helper: best-effort, swallows API errors so it
never blocks connect/disconnect; truncates to Telegram's 120-char cap.
- Wired Online after _mark_connected(), Offline at top of disconnect()
while the bot HTTP client is still alive.
- 9 unit tests + Telegram docs section.
Requested by @ilTrumpista, cc @Teknium.
Adds a Raft platform adapter as a bundled plugin (plugins/platforms/raft/)
connecting Hermes to Raft as an external agent via a wake-channel bridge.
The adapter starts a loopback HTTP endpoint, spawns 'raft agent bridge' as a
child process, and injects content-free wake hints into the gateway session
pipeline. The agent reads/sends messages through the Raft CLI; the adapter
never touches message bodies or delivery cursors. Activity observer hooks
report tool/LLM/session lifecycle events via a bounded at-most-once queue.
Auto-enables when RAFT_PROFILE is set.
Cherry-picked from PR #47629. Authored by skyzh (@xxchan).
Two robustness gaps from community review (#44919):
1. Windows dead-path: replaced bespoke fcntl.flock with gateway.status
_try_acquire_file_lock / _release_file_lock — already cross-platform
(msvcrt on Windows, fcntl on POSIX). Added _release_singleton_lock
helper.
2. Lock fd never released: stored handle is now released explicitly in
both exit paths — CancelledError handler and normal while-loop exit.
Allows in-process stop/restart (tests, embedded use).
Also tightened docstrings — 'corrupt the SQLite DBs' is now specific
(wal_autocheckpoint=0 + concurrent manual WAL checkpoints can corrupt
index pages), matching the module's own concurrency claims.
The gateway's embedded dispatcher has no guard against more than one dispatcher
running concurrently. dispatch_in_gateway defaults to true, so a second gateway
for the same profile (a restart race where the old process is slow to exit) — or
any deployment that runs multiple profile gateways with the default — starts a
second dispatcher loop. As #41448 describes, concurrent dispatchers each run
release_stale_claims() against the same boards, double reclaim frequency, and
re-dispatch slow workers before they finish. In practice they also corrupt the
shared kanban SQLite DBs under concurrent write load.
Add _acquire_singleton_lock(): an exclusive, non-blocking fcntl.flock at the
machine-global kanban root (kanban_home()/kanban/.dispatcher.lock — the board is
shared across profiles by design, so this serialises every gateway, not just one
profile). The first gateway to start its dispatcher holds the lock for its
process lifetime; any other gateway finds it contended, logs, and skips
dispatching while still running for messaging. Falls back to config-only control
on non-POSIX or filesystems without flock.
This is more robust than a per-profile guard because the documented model is
"one dispatcher sweeps all boards" — the contention is across profiles, not just
within one. Closes#41448.
Test: lock is exclusive (held, then contended while held, then held again after
release).
- _guard_named_profile_under_multiplexer: when the default gateway is running
with gateway.multiplex_profiles=on, a named-profile 'hermes gateway run' hard
-errors (pointing at the multiplexer) instead of double-binding that
profile's platforms. Inert unless all hold: this invocation is a named
profile, a default-profile gateway is alive, and its config has multiplexing
on. --force overrides. Wired into run_gateway's guard chain.
- write_runtime_status gains served_profiles: the secondary-adapter startup
records [active] + multiplexed profiles into runtime_status.json so
'hermes status' can show per-profile coverage without a second probe. Absent
for single-profile gateways.
Tests: served_profiles round-trips and is absent by default; guard is inert for
the default profile / under --force / when no default gateway is running.
Bring up adapters for every profile the gateway serves, not just the active
one. Keeps self.adapters as the default/active profile's map (the ~93 existing
self.adapters[...] sites are untouched) and adds secondary profiles under
self._profile_adapters[profile][platform].
- _start_secondary_profile_adapters loops profiles_to_serve(multiplex=True),
skips the active profile (handled by the primary startup loop), and for each
other profile loads its gateway config and creates+connects its enabled
adapters under that profile's _profile_runtime_scope (home + secret scope).
- Each secondary adapter gets _make_profile_message_handler(profile): stamps
source.profile (when unset) before delegating to the shared _handle_message,
so the agent turn and session key resolve to that profile.
- Same-platform credential-conflict detection: _adapter_credential_fingerprint
hashes the adapter's bot token (salted, truncated — never logs the token);
two profiles claiming the same (platform, token) refuse the duplicate with a
clear error naming both, since one token can't be polled twice.
- Port-binding hard-error: a SECONDARY profile that enables a port-binding
platform (webhook, api_server, msgraph_webhook, feishu, wecom_callback,
bluebubbles, sms) is a config error and aborts startup via MultiplexConfigError
— the default profile owns the single shared HTTP listener and serves every
profile through the /p/<profile>/ prefix, so a second bind can only collide.
Distinct from a transient connect failure (which logs + stays alive to retry):
a config error writes gateway_state=startup_failed and exits cleanly with an
actionable message (names the profile, the platform, and the fix). There is no
valid reason to bind a second port once you've opted into a multiplexer.
- Shutdown tears down secondary adapters alongside the primary ones.
- Defensive getattr guards keep partial-construction unit tests (stop(),
_run_agent on bare instances) working.
No-op when multiplex_profiles is off (self._profile_adapters stays empty).
Tests: fingerprint stability/log-safety/distinctness, profile message-handler
stamping (and not overriding an already-stamped source), port-binding hard-error
raises + names the profile/platform, non-binding platform is not rejected, and
the guard set covers every TCP-binding adapter.
Serve webhook inbound for multiple profiles off the one shared listener via a
URL prefix, with no second port bound.
- SessionSource gains a 'profile' field (round-trips through to_dict/from_dict;
omitted when unset so existing serialization is unchanged). It carries which
profile an inbound message was routed to.
- WebhookAdapter registers /p/{profile}/webhooks/{route_name} alongside the
existing /webhooks/{route_name}. _resolve_request_profile validates the
prefix against profiles_to_serve(): None when absent or multiplexing is off
(ignored, handled as default — no spurious 404), the profile name when valid,
_PROFILE_REJECTED (→ 404) when the profile isn't served. The resolved profile
is stamped onto the SessionSource.
- session-key namespacing and the per-turn home/credential scope now prefer
source.profile: SessionStore._resolve_profile_for_key(source),
_session_key_for_source fallback, and _resolve_profile_home_for_source all
honor it (→ the agent turn resolves that profile's config/skills/credentials
via the Phase 2 _profile_runtime_scope).
Constraint: routing inbound needs no per-profile platform credential, but the
agent still needs the routed profile's provider key — delivered by Phase 2's
secret scope. api_server (OpenAI-compatible surface) profile routing is a
focused follow-on; its source-construction path differs from webhook's.
Tests: SessionSource.profile round-trip + namespace drive; _resolve_request_
profile accept/reject/ignore matrix.
The credential gate. When multiplexing is active, a profile's secrets resolve
from a context-local scope, never the process-global os.environ (which in a
multiplexer may hold another profile's keys, and is inherited by every
subprocess spawned with env=dict(os.environ)).
- agent/secret_scope.py: get_secret() backed by a secret-scope contextvar.
FAIL-CLOSED: when multiplex is active and no scope is installed, an unscoped
read RAISES UnscopedSecretError instead of falling back to os.environ — a
missed/new call site crashes loudly at that line rather than leaking a
cross-profile value. Genuinely-global vars (HERMES_*, PATH, kanban paths,
…) keep reading os.environ via an allowlist. load_env_file/build_profile_
secret_scope parse a profile .env into an isolated dict WITHOUT mutating
os.environ. Off by default => transparent os.getenv behavior.
- hermes_cli/runtime_provider.py: all credential/provider/base-url reads go
through _getenv -> get_secret.
- agent/credential_pool.py: env fallbacks route through get_secret (the
~/.hermes/.env-first preference is preserved and already profile-correct via
the home override).
- tools/mcp_tool.py: MCP config interpolation resolves through
get_secret, so a server's picks up the routed profile's value.
- gateway/run.py: set_multiplex_active() at GatewayRunner init; per-turn .env
reload is a no-op for credentials in multiplex mode (secrets come from the
scope, not global env); _profile_runtime_scope context manager combines the
HERMES_HOME override + secret scope; _run_agent wraps _run_agent_inner in
that scope (resolved via _resolve_profile_home_for_source) when multiplexing.
Propagates into the agent worker thread for free via the existing
copy_context() in _run_in_executor_with_context.
Tests: 13 unit (fail-closed, scope isolation, global allowlist, .env parsing
without environ mutation) + 7 E2E (runtime_provider + MCP interpolation prove
two profiles isolated, unscoped read raises, globals still read environ).
Foundations for serving multiple profiles from one gateway process, inert
when off:
- gateway.multiplex_profiles config flag (default false), round-trips through
GatewayConfig and load_gateway_config (top-level + nested gateway.* form).
- hermes_cli.profiles.profiles_to_serve(multiplex): the single chokepoint for
which (profile, HERMES_HOME) pairs the gateway serves. Lightweight dir scan;
active-profile-only when off, default + all named profiles when on.
- build_session_key gains a profile= namespace slot. Default/None reuse the
historical 'agent:main:...' literal BYTE-IDENTICALLY (no session migration,
positional parsers unaffected); a named profile becomes 'agent:<profile>:...'
so two profiles on the same platform/chat never collide.
- SessionStore._resolve_profile_for_key + _session_key_for_source fallback
resolve the namespace from the flag (legacy when off, active profile when on).
Tests: byte-identical-when-off (parametrized), namespace isolation, positional
layout preserved, config round-trip, profiles_to_serve enumeration.
Discord channel-history backfill partitions on Hermes' last self-authored
message. Asynchronous, non-conversational status sends (self-improvement
review bubbles, heartbeats, background-process notifications, update status,
gateway restart/online notices) land as ordinary bot messages, so a delayed
status bump becomes the history boundary and swallows real messages that
arrived after Hermes' actual reply.
Mark these sends at the source via metadata["non_conversational"] (Discord
only; other platforms' metadata is unchanged). The adapter no longer advances
the history-boundary cache for marked sends and persists their IDs to a
sidecar JSON so the cold-start scan can skip them by ID after a restart. A
narrow regex recognizer remains only as an upgrade bridge for status bumps
emitted by an older gateway that pre-dates the marking.
A plain /model <name> switch only lasted for the current session — every
new session reverted to the previously-configured model, so users had to
re-switch every time (e.g. glm-5.1 -> glm-5.2 on every launch).
Persist-by-default is now the behavior across all three /model surfaces
(CLI, gateway, TUI/dashboard), gated by a new config key
model.persist_switch_by_default (default true):
/model <name> switch model (persists to config.yaml)
/model <name> --session switch for this session only
/model <name> --global switch and persist (explicit, unchanged)
The effective persistence is resolved once via resolve_persist_behavior()
in hermes_cli/model_switch.py so --session opts out, --global opts in,
and the config-gated default applies otherwise. --global remains a valid
explicit no-op alias for the new default.
Address correctness gaps found in pre-PR review of the strict matcher:
- Profile selectors can appear on EITHER side of the `gateway` token
(`_apply_profile_override` strips `--profile`/`-p` from anywhere in argv
before argparse), so `hermes gateway --profile work run` and
`python -m hermes_cli.main gateway -p work run` are valid launches the
previous matcher wrongly rejected. Strip `--profile`/`-p`/`--profile=`/`-p=`
from anywhere before locating the subcommand.
- A profile literally named `gateway` (`hermes -p gateway gateway run`) made
the old token scan stop on the profile value; stripping the selector+value
first fixes it.
- Tokenize quote-aware with `shlex` so quoted Windows paths containing spaces
(`"C:\Program Files\Hermes\hermes-gateway.exe"`) are no longer split mid-path
and the dedicated-entrypoint match survives.
Without these, the matcher could MISS a real running gateway -> the opposite
failure (restart/status reporting "down" when up). Adds regression tests for
all three shapes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
`hermes gateway restart` on Windows could take the gateway offline with no
replacement. restart() was stop() -> sleep(1.0) -> start(), but the graceful
drain can run up to ~180s while the detached pythonw process stays alive. The
1s sleep let start() run against the still-draining old process; its
"already running" guard then no-opped, and when the old process finally exited
nothing relaunched it.
Two root causes, both fixed:
1. Loose PID detection. `_scan_gateway_pids` and the gateway.status helpers
used substring matches ("... gateway" in cmdline) for lifecycle decisions,
so they false-matched `gateway status`/`dashboard` siblings and unrelated
processes like `python -m tui_gateway`, plus stale gateway.pid records.
Add a shared strict matcher `looks_like_gateway_command_line()` in
gateway/status.py that requires the real `gateway run` subcommand (or the
dedicated entrypoints), and route `_looks_like_gateway_process`,
`_record_looks_like_gateway`, and `_scan_gateway_pids` through it.
2. restart() race. Wait until the gateway is authoritatively gone
(`get_running_pid()` + strict `_gateway_pids()`) before relaunch; force-kill
once if it lingers and raise rather than start a duplicate; verify the
relaunch produced a running gateway and raise loudly if not (no more
exit-0 silent outage).
Scoped to Windows; systemd/launchd restart paths are already drain-aware.
Adds tests/gateway/test_gateway_command_line_matcher.py.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replaces the tautological test from the original PR (which asserted a
plain assignment it performed itself in the test body) with one that
exercises the actual contracts: _init_cached_agent_for_turn leaves
max_iterations untouched, and the per-turn IterationBudget rebuild
(turn_context.py) propagates a refreshed cap.
Two bugs surfaced from production usage in #37134:
1. Dict choices rendered as Python repr. LLMs sometimes emit
[{"description": "..."}] instead of bare strings; the old
str(c).strip() coercion turned the whole dict into
"{'description': '...'}" on the button label.
Fix: add a _flatten_choice helper that unwraps dicts against
the canonical LLM tool-call user-facing keys (label, description,
text, title) in that order. Dicts with none of those keys are
dropped. The "name" and "value" keys are deliberately NOT in the
priority list — they're Discord-component-shaped fields that
could appear in dicts that aren't meant to be choices (a
developer-error wiring that passes a Button-shaped object);
picking them would leak raw enum values or 4-char model
identifiers onto user-facing buttons.
2. Mid-word truncation on long button labels. The old
choice[:72] + "..." cut at position 72, mid-word. Worse, the
three-char ellipsis ate into the 80-char Discord label cap,
leaving only 75 chars of body.
Fix: budget-aware cut strategy with three tiers:
a. Last space in the trailing half of the budget (word boundary).
b. Last soft boundary (- , . )) in the trailing half — used
only when no word boundary exists.
c. Hard cut at the budget limit (last resort).
Use single U+2026 (…) to fit the cap. Cut AT soft boundaries
(inclusive) so the label ends on the boundary char rather than
on the alpha char that followed it.
Tests:
- test_unwraps_dict_choices_to_description: reproduces the
screenshot in #37134, asserts the Python repr is gone.
- test_unwrap_prefers_description_over_name_in_multi_key_dict:
regression guard for the name-key order in the unwrap list.
- test_unwrap_prefers_label_over_description: regression guard
for label winning over description.
- test_unwrap_does_not_pick_value_or_name_alone: regression
guard for the "name"/"value" fields being absent.
- test_truncates_long_choice_label: 200-char input, asserts
total <= 80 and U+2026.
- test_truncates_long_choice_label_breaks_on_word_boundary:
asserts the cut is on a space, not mid-word.
- test_truncates_long_no_space_choice_on_soft_boundary:
adversarial input where position 76 is mid-word alpha, asserts
the renderer falls back to a soft boundary.
Parity: telegram clarify suite (12 tests) still passes; the
helper is a Discord adapter local, not shared with the gateway.
Follow-up: gateway/platforms/telegram.py has the same str(c).strip()
pattern in its own send_clarify and will need a similar fix
(separate PR to keep this diff reviewable).
Fixes#37134
* fix(relay): enable RELAY platform + normalize dial URL so hosted gateways actually connect
Three bugs blocked a self-provisioned hosted gateway from ever establishing its
inbound relay WS (found while standing up the live staging end-to-end). Each
masked the next; all three are needed for inbound to work.
1. RELAY platform never enabled in config.platforms (gateway/config.py).
register_relay_adapter() puts the adapter in the platform_registry, but
start_gateway()'s connect loop iterates self.config.platforms — which never
contained Platform.RELAY. So the adapter was "registered" but never connected
(logs showed "relay adapter registered" then "No messaging platforms
enabled"). Fix: _apply_env_overrides now enables Platform.RELAY (mirroring
relay_url into extra for the connected-checker) when GATEWAY_RELAY_URL (env)
or gateway.relay_url (yaml) is set. Absent -> no RELAY entry (direct/
single-tenant gateways unaffected).
2. URL scheme not converted for the WS dial (gateway/relay/ws_transport.py).
The relay URL is configured once as the http(s):// base (used as-is for the
provision POST), but websockets.connect rejects http(s):// with "scheme isn't
ws or wss". Fix: _ws_dial_url converts https->wss / http->ws.
3. /relay path not appended (same helper). The connector mounts its
WebSocketServer at path "/relay" and returns HTTP 400 on an upgrade to any
other path. GATEWAY_RELAY_URL is the base (no /relay), so the dial hit "/"
-> 400. Fix: _ws_dial_url ensures the path ends in /relay. Idempotent — a URL
already carrying ws(s):// and/or /relay is unchanged, so provision's
_provision_url (which derives /relay/provision from either form) still works.
Why the cross-repo E2E missed #2/#3: the stub connector binds ws://host:port and
its websockets.serve accepts ANY path, so neither the scheme nor the /relay path
was exercised. Real connector needs both.
Verified live on staging hermes-agent-stg-automated-perception-5054: after the
fixes the gateway logs "Connecting to relay..." -> "✓ relay connected" ->
"Gateway running with 1 platform(s)" against
wss://gateway-gateway.staging-nousresearch.com/relay, stable.
Tests: added _ws_dial_url scheme+path+idempotency cases (test_ws_transport.py)
and RELAY-platform-enablement cases for env + yaml + absent (test_config.py).
Full gateway/relay + config suites green (191 passed).
Relay-adapter lane. EXPERIMENTAL.
* fix(relay): re-attach guild_id to outbound so connector egress resolves the tenant
The final bug in the hosted-relay round-trip. Inbound worked end to end (Discord
-> connector -> bus -> agent WS -> agent runs -> reply), but the reply's egress
was declined by the connector: "discord egress declined: target not routed to an
onboarded tenant".
Cause: the connector's routedEgressGuard resolves the owning tenant from the
OUTBOUND action's metadata.guild_id (Discord's routing discriminator). The
gateway's generic delivery path builds outbound metadata via
run.py _thread_metadata_for_source, which only carries thread_id (and returns
None entirely for a non-threaded message) — so guild_id never reached the
connector, tenant resolution failed, and the shared bot refused to post.
Fix (relay-adapter-local, no perturbation of the generic delivery path or other
platforms): RelayAdapter learns chat_id -> guild_id from each inbound event
(_capture_scope) and re-attaches it to the outbound action's metadata in send()
(_with_scope) when not already present. No-op for chats we never saw inbound
(e.g. DMs) and never overwrites an explicit guild_id.
Verified live on staging hermes-agent-stg-automated-perception-5054: an
@mention in #general now produces a visible bot reply — full multi-tenant relay
round-trip (real Discord -> shared connector bot -> tenant routing -> agent WS ->
reply egress -> Discord).
Tests: _capture_scope/_with_scope reattach, no-scope no-op, explicit-guild_id
preserved (test_relay_adapter.py). Full relay + config suites green (160 passed).
Relay-adapter lane. EXPERIMENTAL.
self_provision_if_managed() gated on is_managed(), but is_managed() means
"NixOS/package-manager-managed" (it keys on HERMES_MANAGED or a ~/.hermes/.managed
marker) — NOT "NAS-hosted". A NAS-provisioned Fly agent sets NEITHER, so the gate
was always False and relay self-provision SILENTLY no-oped on exactly the hosted
agents it was built for. Caught live: a staging agent with GATEWAY_RELAY_URL
correctly stamped logged "No messaging platforms enabled" and never dialed the
connector; HERMES_MANAGED was unset on the machine. The unit tests had mocked
is_managed()->True, so they passed while the real trigger never fired (mocked-
trigger blind spot).
Fix: drop the is_managed() gate and rename self_provision_if_managed ->
self_provision_relay. The real trigger is now "relay_url() set + no pinned secret
+ a resolvable NAS token", which is both NAS-independent and self-guarding:
- NAS-hosted agent: GATEWAY_RELAY_URL + no pinned secret + bootstrapped NAS
token -> self-provisions.
- Self-hosted + `hermes gateway enroll`: pinned GATEWAY_RELAY_SECRET -> skipped
(existing secret-present guard).
- Self-hosted, unenrolled, no NAS identity: resolve_nous_access_token() fails
-> graceful no-op (existing fail-soft path).
Security: unchanged trust model. The connector still derives tenant from the
validated NAS token; this only broadens WHEN the provision attempt fires, and
every broadened case is still guarded by token-resolution + pinned-secret-skip.
Tests: replaced the (wrong) "skips when not managed" test with a regression test
proving a NAS host where is_managed()==False STILL provisions; renamed all call
sites; added a "no NAS token -> non-fatal skip" test for the self-hosted branch.
88 relay tests pass.
Relay-adapter lane. EXPERIMENTAL.
The connector now delivers inbound (messages + interrupts) over the gateway's
OUTBOUND /relay WebSocket, not a signed HTTP POST to an inbound endpoint. The
gateway needs no inbound HTTP port — which is what makes hosted gateways (no
public IP) able to receive inbound at all.
- gateway/relay/adapter.py: connect() wires set_interrupt_inbound_handler(
self.on_interrupt) so connector->gateway interrupt_inbound frames bridge into
the existing per-session interrupt path (the inbound message handler was
already wired). Removed _maybe_start_inbound_receiver() + the _inbound_runner
lifecycle — there is no HTTP receiver anymore.
- gateway/relay/inbound_receiver.py: deleted (the signed-HTTP InboundDelivery
receiver).
- gateway/relay/__init__.py: removed relay_inbound_config() (dead with the
receiver gone). The delivery key is still set in-process by self-provision for
forward-compat but is no longer consumed for inbound.
- docs/relay-connector-contract.md: §3 rewritten — inbound is the WS back-channel
routed cross-instance via the connector's relay bus; §5 interrupt + §6 auth
table updated; the old signed-HTTP-POST + per-tenant-delivery-key-signing path
is documented as superseded. gatewayEndpoint noted as passthrough-plane only.
Tests: stub_connector grows set_interrupt_inbound_handler + push_interrupt;
new test_relay_interrupt case proves connect() wires BOTH inbound handlers and an
interrupt_inbound frame over the WS cancels the right session. Removed the
HTTP-receiver test; updated the crypto-shedding scan + self-provision delivery-key
assertion. 88 relay tests pass.
EXPERIMENTAL. Pairs with gateway-gateway (relay bus + WsGatewayDelivery) and the
NAS GATEWAY_RELAY_URL stamp. The cross-repo E2E (connector repo) proves the full
multi-instance path against this production adapter code.
The gateway half of relay Phase 3. On a MANAGED boot with relay configured and
no secret pinned, the runtime self-provisions its relay credentials IN-PROCESS:
resolve the agent's own Nous access token (resolve_nous_access_token) -> POST
the connector's /relay/provision asserting its own endpoint + route keys ->
set GATEWAY_RELAY_ID/SECRET/DELIVERY_KEY into os.environ so the immediately-
following register_relay_adapter() reads them and dials out authenticated.
No human, no enrollment token, no disk write — the creds live only in process
memory (save_env_value refuses under managed anyway, and keeping the secret off
any volume is the stronger posture). Stateless: process-env creds don't survive
a restart, so a managed container re-provisions every boot; the connector's
rotation window covers a still-connected prior instance. An explicitly-pinned
GATEWAY_RELAY_SECRET is respected (skip). Self-hosted is unchanged: humans keep
using `hermes gateway enroll`.
Endpoint provenance is gateway-asserted (GATEWAY_RELAY_ENDPOINT +
GATEWAY_RELAY_ROUTE_KEYS, env or gateway.relay_* config) — uniform code path
whether the operator sets it (self-hosted) or NAS stamps it (hosted, the only
case NAS knows the public URL). Both absent -> outbound-only provisioning
(credentials, no inbound routes). The connector scopes the asserted endpoint to
the verified tenant, so it stays within the security model.
- gateway/relay/__init__.py: relay_endpoint(), relay_route_keys(),
_provision_url(), _post_provision(), self_provision_if_managed() (never
raises — a provision failure logs and boots without relay auth).
- gateway/run.py: call self_provision_if_managed() immediately before
register_relay_adapter() in the startup path.
Tests: 12 unit (trigger logic, respect-pinned-secret, in-process env wiring,
endpoint+routes vs outbound-only, fail-soft on token/connector failure);
mutation-checked (drop is_managed guard / pinned-secret guard -> tests fail).
Cross-repo live E2E driver lands on the connector side (depends on this).
EXPERIMENTAL: relay auth scheme may change until >=2 Class-1 platforms validate.
Phase 4E (E.1 + E.2). The inbound side of Chronos: NAS POSTs the agent when a
one-shot fires; the agent verifies a NAS-minted JWT and runs the job.
E.1 — plugins/cron/chronos/verify.py:
- verify_nas_fire_token(token, expected_audience, jwks_or_key, issuer): verifies
signature against the NAS JWKS (RS/ES family; symmetric rejected), aud == this
agent, exp/nbf, iss, and purpose == "cron_fire" (so a general agent JWT can't
be replayed against the fire endpoint). Returns claims or None; never raises.
Crypto delegated to PyJWT[crypto] (already a declared dep) — no hand-rolled
JWT, no new dependency. No key configured → refuse (never unsigned-decode a
security boundary).
- get_fire_verifier(): pluggable indirection so the DQ-4 escape hatch
(direct per-job cron-key) can swap in with no handler change.
E.2 — gateway/platforms/api_server.py:
- POST /api/cron/fire (registered only when _CRON_AVAILABLE). Authenticated by
the NAS-JWT via get_fire_verifier() — NOT API_SERVER_KEY (NAS holds no API
key; this is the only inbound that triggers remote job execution, so it gets
its own purpose-scoped check). Verifier args come from cron.chronos.* config.
401 on bad/missing/forged token. 400 on missing job_id. On success: 202 +
fire_due runs in the background (so a long agent turn never trips NAS's HTTP
timeout); the store CAS claim inside fire_due de-dupes a scheduler retry.
Tests:
- test_chronos_verify (11): REAL RS256 signing — valid→claims, wrong-aud,
missing/wrong purpose, expired, wrong-iss, tampered-signature (attacker key),
no-key-refuse, empty-token, JWKS-URL key resolution, get_fire_verifier.
- test_cron_fire_webhook (5): valid→202+fire, invalid→401+no-fire, missing
token→401, missing job_id→400, and fire path does NOT require API_SERVER_KEY.
api_server regression suites (214) green.
E.3 (NAS endpoints) is a separate cross-repo PR; the wire contract lands next
(docs/chronos-managed-cron-contract.md).
* feat(relay): authenticate the connector⇄gateway WS channel
The relay gateway may be customer-managed and internet-exposed, so the
connector⇄gateway channel is itself authenticated (distinct from the
platform crypto the relay path sheds). Add gateway/relay/auth.py — a
Python port of the connector's HMAC token + delivery-signature schemes
(relayAuthToken.ts / deliverySigning.ts), verified byte-for-byte against
the connector's compiled TypeScript via cross-language test vectors.
Present an Authorization bearer on the /relay WS upgrade keyed by the
per-gateway secret (resolved from GATEWAY_RELAY_ID / GATEWAY_RELAY_SECRET
in env or config). The connector rejects an unauthenticated/invalid/
revoked upgrade with close 4401.
* feat(relay): signed-HTTP inbound delivery receiver
The connector delivers normalized inbound events to a tenant's gateway
over a signed HTTP POST, not the outbound /relay WS: the connector
instance owning a platform socket is generally not the instance a given
gateway dialed out to, so inbound targets a tenant endpoint that may
load-balance across gateway instances.
Add gateway/relay/inbound_receiver.py — verifies x-relay-signature /
x-relay-timestamp over the EXACT raw request bytes (re-serializing would
break the HMAC: JS JSON.stringify is compact, Python json.dumps spaces)
against the per-tenant delivery key verify list within a 300s replay
window, then dispatches messages to handle_message and interrupts to the
interrupt handler. Wire it into the adapter lifecycle (start in connect()
when a delivery key + bind port are configured, tear down in disconnect();
a purely-outbound dev gateway runs without it).
Refine test_relay_sheds_crypto to distinguish PLATFORM crypto (Discord
ed25519, Twilio/WeCom HMAC — still shed) from the connector⇄gateway
CHANNEL auth (intended): auth.py / inbound_receiver.py are exempt from
the platform-symbol scan but still banned from importing platform-crypto
modules, plus a positive guard that auth.py uses only stdlib hmac/hashlib.
* feat(relay): hermes gateway enroll CLI
Add the gateway half of zero-touch enrollment. `hermes gateway enroll`
resolves a fresh Nous Portal access token (the tenant-proving identity),
POSTs {enrollmentToken, gatewayId} to the connector's /relay/enroll, and
persists GATEWAY_RELAY_ID / GATEWAY_RELAY_SECRET / GATEWAY_RELAY_DELIVERY_KEY
to ~/.hermes/.env. The per-gateway secret authenticates the WS upgrade;
the per-tenant delivery key verifies signed inbound deliveries.
Refuses under is_managed() (hosted installs get the secret stamped in by
the orchestrator). Added as an 'enroll' subcommand on the existing
gateway subparser — not a new top-level command.
* docs(relay): inbound is signed HTTP, not WS; document channel auth
Fix the stale contract: §3/§5 said inbound rode the WS socket (single-
instance only, predates the multi-instance socket-ownership + channel-auth
model). Inbound + connector→gateway interrupt are signed HTTP POSTs to the
tenant endpoint. Add §6.1 documenting the two channel-auth schemes (per-
gateway WS-upgrade secret, per-tenant inbound delivery key) and how they
differ from the platform crypto the relay path sheds.
* test(relay): update build_gateway_parser callers for cmd_gateway_enroll
The enroll subcommand added cmd_gateway_enroll as a required keyword-only
arg to build_gateway_parser, but two existing parser-extraction tests still
called it with only cmd_gateway/cmd_proxy — failing CI with TypeError.
Thread the new handler through both call sites and add a test asserting
`gateway enroll` dispatches to cmd_gateway_enroll with its flags parsed.
- test_ws_transport.py: drives WebSocketRelayTransport against a REAL in-process
websockets server (not a mock socket): handshake (hello->descriptor), inbound
frame -> handler, outbound request/response correlation, follow_up routing,
and clean disconnect failing pending waiters. Skips if websockets is absent.
- test_relay_registration.py: rewritten for the config-driven gate — registers
when GATEWAY_RELAY_URL is set / an explicit url is passed / force=True; no-op
without a URL; trailing slash stripped; adapter constructs through the registry.
Full relay suite: 57 passed.
The relay outbound surface had send/edit/typing but no way to act on a
SHARED-identity capability (e.g. a Discord interaction follow-up token,
~15min) that the connector captured + stripped at the edge. Under A2 that
credential never reaches the gateway, so the gateway can't just 'send with
the token' — it needs a semantic op naming the session it's already in.
Adds the follow_up op end to end on the gateway side:
- RelayTransport.send_follow_up(action): protocol method. Action carries
op='follow_up' + session_key + kind + content (+ metadata) and NO token.
- RelayAdapter.send_follow_up(session_key, kind, content, metadata): builds
that action and returns a SendResult. The connector resolves the real
capability (its resolveOutboundCapability), enforces the tenant match so
tenant B can't wield tenant A's capability, and egresses; success=False
when the capability is absent/expired/mismatched (nothing to retry — a
leaked gateway holds zero capability material).
- StubConnector records follow_ups + a canned next_follow_up_result.
Tests: round-trips without a token; the wire action carries only session
refs (no credential value field — the 'kind' string is a type ref, not the
secret); failure surfaces when the connector can't resolve; no-transport
fails cleanly. 55 passed. §4 doc entry follows in the contract-rewrite commit.
Under the A2 trust model the connector is the SOLE crypto/identity
boundary: it verifies/decrypts every inbound platform payload at the edge
(it holds the tenant secrets), normalizes to a tenant-scoped MessageEvent,
and forwards only the sanitized event. The gateway re-validates nothing —
it cannot without being handed the shared signing secret, which on a
shared bot is itself the cross-tenant leak.
The relay path already imports no platform-crypto today; this locks that
in as an enforced invariant so nobody bolts re-validation (Discord
ed25519, Twilio HMAC, WeCom BizMsgCrypt, generic webhook signature checks)
onto the relay later and silently re-couples the gateway to platform
secrets it must never hold. Verification stays in the direct platform
adapters (gateway/platforms/*) which serve non-relay deployments.
- test_relay_package_imports_no_platform_crypto: AST-walks gateway/relay/*
and fails on any import of a platform-crypto/verification module.
- test_relay_package_calls_no_signature_verification: fails on any
verification-symbol reference (ed25519/hmac/bizmsg/verify_*).
Invariants (assert the relation 'relay re-validates nothing'), not frozen
snapshots. Verified the guard bites: injecting a wecom_crypto import makes
it fail, removing it goes green. docs §6 rewrite follows in a later commit.
The Phase 1 exit gate requires BOTH Discord and Telegram to round-trip
through the relay stub, but test_relay_roundtrip.py only covered Discord.
Add the Telegram companion exercising its distinct discriminator profile:
- no guild_id — two chats isolate on chat_id alone
- forum topics share one chat_id and isolate by thread_id (the Telegram
analog of Discord per-guild isolation), shared across participants by
default (thread_sessions_per_user=False)
- DM isolation by chat_id
- utf16 len_unit + markdown_v2 dialect round-trip and configure the adapter
- outbound send round-trips through the stub
Proves the CapabilityDescriptor + build_session_key generalize beyond
Discord, not just the struct (which the descriptor unit tests already
covered).
Add an invariant test pinning docs/relay-connector-contract.md to the
Python source of truth so the doc (which the connector repo mirrors by
hand) cannot silently drift:
- CapabilityDescriptor §2 table ⟷ dataclass fields + required/optional
- SessionSource wire keys (to_dict output) ⟷ §3 documented fields
- per-platform discriminator columns exist as real SessionSource fields
- guard that is_bot stays off the wire until deliberately promoted
Writing the test surfaced a real gap: §3 only enumerated 5 discriminators
in its per-platform table while to_dict() emits 12 keys. Seven wire keys
the connector must populate (chat_name, chat_topic, user_id_alt,
chat_id_alt, parent_chat_id, message_id, user_name) were undocumented —
a connector author reading the doc would never know to set them. Added a
complete SessionSource wire-field table to §3. The connector's existing
contract.ts already carries all 12, so no connector change is needed; the
doc was the lagging artifact.
The platform-connected-checker invariant test requires every built-in
Platform enum member to have either a generic token path or a bespoke
entry in _PLATFORM_CONNECTED_CHECKERS. Platform.RELAY was added without
one, so test_all_builtins_have_checker_or_generic_token_path failed.
Relay dials OUT to a connector and is 'connected' once an endpoint URL
is configured (extra['relay_url'] or extra['url']); the capability
descriptor is negotiated at handshake time, so the URL is the only
config-level signal in the experimental phase. Add the checker plus a
synthetic-config case exercising its True path.
CI guard: fails if gateway/ or plugins/ ever imports the test-only stub
connector or defines StubConnector. Matches code leaks (imports / class defs),
not prose mentions, so the transport.py docstring reference to the stub's path
is allowed.
Phase 1 complete. Task 1.6 of the gateway-relay plan.
RelayAdapter.on_interrupt(session_key, chat_id) bridges a connector-delivered
mid-turn /stop into the existing interrupt_session_activity path, setting the
per-session _active_sessions Event and clearing typing — cancelling exactly the
targeted session's turn without touching siblings (mirrors test_stop_thread_
sibling isolation). Transport.send_interrupt carries the gateway-side egress to
the connector for socket-owner routing.
Phase 1, Task 1.4 of the gateway-relay plan.
register_relay_adapter() registers the generic 'relay' platform via the same
PlatformRegistry path as plugin adapters — no core dispatch changes. OFF by
default (dark-launch): only registers when HERMES_GATEWAY_RELAY is truthy (or
force=True for tests), so existing single-tenant/direct deployments are
unaffected. Factory builds a transport-less RelayAdapter with a placeholder
descriptor; the real descriptor is negotiated at handshake.
Phase 1, Task 1.3 of the gateway-relay plan.
Defines RelayTransport (lifecycle/handshake/inbound/outbound/interrupt) as the
gateway<->connector wire contract; RelayAdapter.connect now registers an inbound
handler that bridges connector-delivered MessageEvents into handle_message.
Adds an in-memory StubConnector under tests/ and an E2E round-trip proving:
connect registers the handler, inbound events reach the adapter, guild_id drives
build_session_key isolation (two guilds -> two keys; same guild/channel/user ->
one), outbound send round-trips, get_chat_info is proxied.
Phase 1, Task 1.2 of the gateway-relay plan.
One BasePlatformAdapter subclass that reads its capability profile from a
CapabilityDescriptor: MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH attribute, message_len_fn (table-driven
by len_unit: chars=len, utf16=Telegram-style code units), supports_draft_streaming.
Implements the four abstract methods (connect/disconnect/send/get_chat_info) by
delegating to an injected RelayTransport (full protocol lands in Task 1.2). Adds
Platform.RELAY enum member. No per-platform gateway code.
Phase 1, Task 1.1 of the gateway-relay plan.
CapabilityDescriptor.from_platform_entry() projects an existing PlatformEntry
(label, max_message_length, emoji, platform_hint, pii_safe, name) into a
descriptor, proving the descriptor is a projection of existing config rather
than a parallel concept. Runtime-only capabilities (len_unit, draft/edit/
thread/markdown) are caller-supplied. max_message_length==0 ('no limit') maps
to the stream_consumer 4096 default.
Phase 0 complete. Task 0.3 of the gateway-relay plan.
Behavioral regression harness locking the capability surface that the future
RelayAdapter must reproduce: the abstract-method set (connect/disconnect/send/
get_chat_info), message_len_fn default, supports_draft_streaming default, and
the stream_consumer MAX_MESSAGE_LENGTH attribute read. Passes on main before
any RelayAdapter exists.
Phase 0, Task 0.1 of the gateway-relay plan.
Follow-up to salvaged PR #41633: the timestamp prefix injection was
unconditional. Gate the in-context render behind
gateway.message_timestamps.enabled (default false) at both the live-message
and history-replay sites; timestamp metadata is still captured + persisted
regardless so the toggle can be flipped on later. Add DEFAULT_CONFIG entry,
docs, and gate tests.
Consolidates these related Amy fork patches:
- 429830f39 feat(gateway): inject message timestamps into user messages for LLM context
- 3c3d6fac0 fix: handle both ISO string and epoch float timestamps in history replay
- 2874f7725 feat: human-friendly timestamp format with weekday and timezone name
- 3735f4c8b fix: render gateway message timestamps once
Cover #47375 fix: record-on-rich-send + lookup-on-reply round trip,
lookup miss leaving reply_to_text None, and precedence (native quote
and echoed caption both win over the index fallback).
