When a MoA preset is selected, each reference model's answer now renders in the
CLI as a thinking-style block labelled with its source model, BEFORE the
aggregator responds — so the mixture-of-agents process is visible instead of a
silent pause. The aggregator's response (and its tool actions) follow as normal.
Mechanism (shared seam, all surfaces):
- MoAChatCompletions/MoAClient take an optional reference_callback and emit
'moa.reference' (index/count/label/text) per reference, then 'moa.aggregating'
(aggregator label) once. agent_init wires this to the agent's
tool_progress_callback, which every surface already consumes — so the events
reach CLI/TUI/desktop/gateway with no new plumbing.
- CLI _on_tool_progress renders 'moa.reference' as a labelled '┊ ◇ Reference
i/n — <model>' header + a thinking-style preview (reusing _emit_reasoning_
preview), and 'moa.aggregating' as a spinner transition. Display-only; never
touches message history (cache-safe).
Turn-scoped reference cache: the agent loop calls the facade once per tool-loop
iteration, but the advisory message view is identical across iterations within a
turn, so references are now run AND displayed once per user turn (keyed by the
advisory view's signature) instead of re-running/re-spamming on every iteration.
This also cuts reference API cost from O(iterations) back to O(turns).
Verified live via interactive PTY on the opus-gpt preset (gpt-5.5 + opus refs):
reference blocks render once per turn, labelled by model, before the aggregator;
fresh blocks on each new turn; aggregator tool actions still execute.
Follow-up: TUI/desktop rich rendering + gateway batched-summary already receive
the events via tool_progress_callback; their surface-specific renderers are a
separate change.
In the interactive CLI, the aggregator's tool calls under a MoA preset (or
any non-streaming model call, e.g. copilot-acp) appeared to overwrite each
other instead of building scrollable history. Each tool only updated the
transient spinner line; no committed scrollback line was printed.
Root cause: persistent tool lines in _on_tool_progress's tool.completed
branch were gated on tool_progress_mode in {all, new}, omitting 'verbose'.
Streaming models hid the bug because _on_tool_gen_start commits a 'preparing'
line per tool during streaming; non-streaming calls (MoA forces
_use_streaming=False) never emit that, so under 'verbose' there was no
committed line at all — only the self-overwriting spinner.
'verbose' is strictly more than 'all', so it now commits the same scrollback
line. Verified live via interactive PTY on the MoA opus-gpt preset: three
terminal calls in turn 1 and two in turn 2 each render as separate persistent
lines.
PR #6a1aa420e coupled `display.tool_progress: verbose` (a per-tool display
toggle for full args / results / think blocks) to `self.verbose` — which
controls root-logger DEBUG level. Result: setting tool_progress: verbose
in config silently flipped every module in the process to DEBUG and
flooded the terminal with internal logging, far beyond just full tool
calls.
The two concepts are separate:
- `tool_progress_mode == 'verbose'` → display behavior (tool rendering)
- `self.verbose` → logging behavior (root logger → DEBUG, line 9795)
This change keeps PR #6a1aa420e's argparse.SUPPRESS / config-fallback
plumbing but severs the verbose-display → debug-logging link.
Changes:
- cli.py:2868 — `self.verbose` only follows explicit `verbose=` arg; no
longer auto-True when tool_progress_mode == 'verbose'.
- cli.py:_toggle_verbose — slash-cycle through tool progress modes no
longer flips `self.verbose` / `agent.verbose_logging` / `agent.quiet_mode`.
- cli.py:9355 — fix misleading label (drop 'and debug logs').
- tui_gateway/server.py:_make_agent — same decoupling on the TUI side
(verbose_logging no longer derived from tool_progress_mode).
- tests/cli/test_tool_progress_scrollback.py — invert the test that
asserted the broken coupling; add coverage for explicit `--verbose`
still enabling DEBUG independent of tool_progress.
Live verified:
- tool_progress: verbose, no --verbose flag → 0 DEBUG/INFO log lines
- --verbose flag explicit → 32 DEBUG/INFO log lines (as expected)
The original PR #17194 description claimed test_display_tool_preview.py
but only ever shipped test_display_todo_progress.py. Add the missing
coverage for the failure-suffix path:
- _trim_error: whitespace strip, length cap, File-not-found path collapse
- _detect_tool_failure: terminal exit codes, memory full, structured
{error}/{message} extraction, malformed JSON, None result
- get_cute_tool_message E2E: read_file failure, terminal exit-only,
terminal stderr message, memory full, success path, no-result path
Also update test_tool_progress_scrollback.test_error_suffix_on_failed_tool
to reflect the new behavior: the generic '[error]' fallback in cli.py
has been removed; failure suffixes now come from the result-aware
_detect_tool_failure (e.g. '[exit 1]', '[File not found: x]').
The TUI transition (4970705, f83e86d) replaced stacked per-tool history
lines with a single live-updating spinner widget. While the spinner
provides a nice live timer, it removed the scrollback history that
users relied on to see what the agent did during a session.
This restores stacked tool progress lines in 'all' and 'new' modes by
printing persistent scrollback lines via _cprint() when tools complete,
in addition to the existing live spinner display.
Behavior per mode:
- off: no scrollback lines, no spinner (unchanged)
- new: scrollback line on completion, skipping consecutive same-tool repeats
- all: scrollback line on every tool completion
- verbose: no scrollback (run_agent.py handles verbose output directly)
Implementation:
- Store function_args from tool.started events in _pending_tool_info
- On tool.completed, pop stored args and format via get_cute_tool_message()
- FIFO queue per function_name handles concurrent tool execution
- 'new' mode tracks _last_scrollback_tool for dedup
- State cleared at end of agent run
Reported by community user Mr.D — the stacked history provides
transparency into what the agent is doing, which builds trust.
Addresses user report from Discord about lost tool call visibility.
